Youâ€™ll recall that QE2 â€” the fancy name for the Fedâ€™s market manipulations â€” ends June 30. There is no particular reason why that date should be anything special. Itâ€™s the official end of QE2. But the market will likely anticipate the end of QE2 before it actually ends.
As Barronâ€™s put it recently:
â€œJust as risk markets began to rally months ahead of the actual start last November of the Federal Reserveâ€™s program to purchase an additional $600 billion of Treasury securities, these same markets may be beginning to anticipate the end of the central bankâ€™s buying.â€
If this holds true, then the market ought to fall as QE peters out, all other things being equal (which they never are).
There are many ways to show how the Fed is turning the market into its own personal yo-yo. The easiest way to see how the market spins up and down with a jerk of the Fedâ€™s massive balance sheet is to plot the two against each other. When the Fed expands its balance sheet (by buying stuff, thereby putting money out there), the market rises. When it contracts its balance sheet (by selling stuff, thereby taking in cash), the market sags. Here is a chart that shows the tight correlation since the March 2009 bottom:
Whatever happens, you can rely on the herd of investors to reliably do the wrong thing. Most investors sell near bottoms and buy near tops, though that is the exact opposite of what they should be doing.
The most arresting recent statistic on this front that Iâ€™ve seen comes from Thomson Reutersâ€™ Lipper data, which tracks money flows into mutual funds. Many investors stayed away during 2009. Even in 2010, the trickle of money heading to stock mutual funds was hardly anything.
But this past February, after the market had doubled from its lows and gained 30% since August, investors finally decided itâ€™s a good time to go back in the market. In one week in February, investors poured more money into funds than they had in all of 2010 â€” about $7 billion.
A recent issue of The Economist provided an excellent illustration of how most investors do exactly the wrong thing in their timing efforts. The financial magazine produced a chart showing how investors tend to chase after the mutual funds that have been doing well, and tend to sell the funds that have been doing poorly. In general, these mutual fund investors should have done the exact opposite.
As the Economistâ€™s story details, the funds attracting the largest amounts of new investment tended to underperform after all the money arrived. By contrast, the funds that suffered the heaviest outflows tended to outperform after all the money left!
Itâ€™s a long-held fallacy that successful investors are great market timers. Many people think that successfully predicting where the market is going to go is an important part of doing well in markets. It isnâ€™t.
As Warren Buffett says, â€œForecasts may tell you a great deal about the forecaster; they tell you nothing about the future.â€ He isnâ€™t the only one to have come to this conclusion. The most successful investors I know and have studied donâ€™t bother trying to predict the market.
In â€œBecoming Rich,â€ Mark Tier studied the investment habits of three great investors: George Soros, Warren Buffett and Carl Icahn. Tier concludes, â€œSuccessful investors donâ€™t rely on predicting the marketâ€™s next move. Indeed, both Buffett and Soros would be the first to admit that if they relied on their market predictions, theyâ€™d go broke. Prediction is the bread and butter of investment newsletter and mutual fund marketing â€” not of successful investing.â€
Thatâ€™s why you donâ€™t see me drawing charts with lines on them guessing where the market is headed next. Of course, itâ€™s fun to guess what might happen, but realize these are guesses. When it comes to actually putting money to work, you ought to rely on something sterner, like good old-fashioned research on what you own.
When that process of digging around for stuff turns up fewer ideas, then you have to be willing to let the cash accumulate for a while. In my personal account, Iâ€™m up to 25% in cash. Itâ€™s just the natural outcome of my own bottom-up research.
Iâ€™ve issued a lot of â€œsellâ€ recommendations this year in my investment letter, Capital & Crisis. And I havenâ€™t added many new ideas so far. This is not a market call, but the end result of a process of buying whatâ€™s cheap and selling (or avoiding) what I think is expensive or unattractive.
So QE2 is background noise, something we have to recognize is distorting markets. But we still have to do the spadework of investing â€” digging around, thinking and digging around some more. Add to that a lot of patience.
One of my favorite investors was Phil Carret, who died in 1998 at the age of 101 and who worked at his art until almost the very end. He witnessed more than 30 bull markets and more than 30 bear markets over a lifetime of investing. Warren Buffett admired him, often inviting him to Berkshireâ€™s annual meeting and calling Carret the â€œLou Gehrig of investing.â€ (Gehrig was the â€œIron Horseâ€ of baseball, before his consecutive games played record fell to Baltimoreâ€™s Cal Ripken Jr.).
When asked on the Louis Rukeyser show in 1995 what was the single most important thing he had learned about investing over his long career, Carret had a one-word answer: â€œPatience.â€
The Sinking of QE2 originally appeared in the Daily Reckoning. The Daily Reckoning provides over half a million subscribers with literary economic perspective, global market analysis, and contrarian investment ideas. Bill Bonner, the founder of the the Daily Reckoning released his latest book Dice Have No Memory: Big Bets & Bad Economics From Paris to the Pampas in April 2011.
Read more here:
The Sinking of QE2
The Daily Reckoning is a contrarian e-letter, brought to you by New York Times best-selling authors Bill Bonner and Addison Wiggin since 1999. The DR looks at the economic world-at-large and offers its major players – investors, politicians, economists and the average consumer – some much-needed constructive criticism.
Mutual Fund, Uncategorized